Head to Head
New York City FC9 - 8 - 11
28 matches
Columbus Crew
9Wins11
48Goals47
1.7Avg Goals/Match1.7
6Clean Sheets2
8Home Wins8
1Away Wins3
Biggest win: 4-1 (2016)Biggest win: 4-1 (2017)
Note: head-to-head data is available from 2010 onwards (2012 for MLS). Earlier matchups are not included.
Upcoming
Previous Meetings (28)
W
Wed
Sep 17
2025
New York City FC
Columbus Crew3
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 26Yankee Stadium, BronxSergiy Boyko, Ukraine
D
Sat
Mar 22
2025
Columbus CrewNew York City FC0
0
HT 0-0Regular Season - 5Lower.com Field, ColumbusRubiel Vazquez, USA
L
Sat
Aug 31
2024
Columbus CrewNew York City FC4
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 39Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioT. Unkel
D
Sat
Aug 17
2024
Columbus CrewNew York City FC1
1
HT 1-1PENQuarter-finalsLower.com Field, Columbus, OhioJ. Dickerson
L
Fri
Jun 14
2024
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
3
HT 1-0Regular Season - 25Yankee Stadium, New York CityA. Da Silva
D
Sat
Jul 8
2023
Columbus CrewNew York City FC1
1
HT 0-0Regular Season - 31Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioS. Boiko
D
Sat
Jun 17
2023
New York City FCColumbus Crew1
1
HT 0-0Regular Season - 26Yankee Stadium, New York CityP. Lauziere
L
Sat
Aug 6
2022
Columbus CrewNew York City FC3
2
HT 2-1Regular Season - 34Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioR. Vazquez
W
Sat
May 14
2022
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
0
HT 1-0Regular Season - 15Yankee Stadium, New York CityM. de Oliveira
W
Fri
Jul 30
2021
New York City FCColumbus Crew4
1
HT 2-0Regular Season - 21Yankee Stadium, New York CityA. Kelly
L
Sat
Jul 17
2021
Columbus CrewNew York City FC2
1
HT 1-0Regular Season - 17Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioR. Touchan
L
Sun
May 23
2021
New York City FCColumbus Crew1
2
HT 1-0Regular Season - 8Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New JerseyD. Fischer
L
Mon
Oct 19
2020
Columbus CrewNew York City FC3
1
HT 1-0Regular Season - 21MAPFRE Stadium, Columbus, OhioA. Chilowicz
W
Mon
Aug 24
2020
New York City FCColumbus Crew1
0
HT 0-0Regular Season - 5Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New JerseyN. Saghafi
L
Sun
Mar 1
2020
Columbus CrewNew York City FC1
0
HT 0-0Regular Season - 2MAPFRE Stadium, Columbus, OhioR. Touchan
W
Wed
Aug 21
2019
New York City FCColumbus Crew1
0
HT 1-0Regular Season - 32Yankee Stadium, New YorkAllen Chapman, USA
D
Sat
Jun 1
2019
Columbus CrewNew York City FC2
2
HT 1-0Regular Season - 18MAPFRE Stadium, ColumbusJoseph Dickerson, USA
L
Sun
Sep 2
2018
Columbus CrewNew York City FC2
1
HT 0-0Regular Season - 32MAPFRE Stadium, ColumbusAlan Kelly, Ireland
W
Sat
Jul 14
2018
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
0
HT 0-0Regular Season - 22Yankee Stadium, New YorkVillarrea Armando, USA
W
Sun
Nov 5
2017
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
0
HT 1-0MLS Cup - Conference Semi-finalsYankee Stadium (New York City)
L
Wed
Nov 1
2017
Columbus CrewNew York City FC4
1
HT 1-0MLS Cup - Conference Semi-finalsMAPFRE Stadium (Columbus, Ohio)
D
Sun
Oct 22
2017
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
2
HT 2-1Regular Season - 38Yankee Stadium, New YorkIsmail Elfath, USA
W
Sat
Apr 29
2017
Columbus CrewNew York City FC2
3
HT 1-1Regular Season - 9MAPFRE Stadium, ColumbusChris Penso, USA
W
Sun
Oct 23
2016
New York City FCColumbus Crew4
1
HT 1-0Regular Season - 34Yankee Stadium, New YorkJose Carlos Rivero, USA
D
Sat
Aug 13
2016
Columbus CrewNew York City FC3
3
HT 0-1Regular Season - 24MAPFRE Stadium, ColumbusSorin Stoica, USA
L
Sat
Apr 16
2016
Columbus CrewNew York City FC3
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 6MAPFRE Stadium, ColumbusTed Unkel, USA
L
Sat
Aug 29
2015
New York City FCColumbus Crew1
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 26Yankee Stadium, New YorkJuan Guzman, USA
D
Wed
Aug 19
2015
Columbus CrewNew York City FC2
2
HT 1-0Regular Season - 25MAPFRE Stadium, ColumbusAllen Chapman, USA