Major League SoccerRegular Season - 24FT
Columbus Crew
3-3
HT (0-1)
New York City FCMAPFRE Stadium · Columbus
Last 5 meetings
Full H2HL
Wed
Sep 17
2025
New York City FC
Columbus Crew3
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 26Yankee Stadium, BronxSergiy Boyko, Ukraine
D
Sat
Mar 22
2025
Columbus CrewNew York City FC0
0
HT 0-0Regular Season - 5Lower.com Field, ColumbusRubiel Vazquez, USA
W
Sat
Aug 31
2024
Columbus CrewNew York City FC4
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 39Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioT. Unkel
D
Sat
Aug 17
2024
Columbus CrewNew York City FC1
1
HT 1-1PENQuarter-finalsLower.com Field, Columbus, OhioJ. Dickerson
W
Fri
Jun 14
2024
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
3
HT 1-0Regular Season - 25Yankee Stadium, New York CityA. Da Silva
Note: advanced (ASA) stats are processed on a delay and may lag basic stats by up to a day after match completion.
Match events
- 41'F. Lampard
- 49'Justin MeramAssist: W. Francis
- 54'J. Harrison ↑T. Taylor ↓
- 61'H. Jiménez ↑W. Francis ↓
- 69'R. Matarrita ↑R. Allen ↓
- 74'C. Mabwati ↑F. Higuaín ↓
- 80'E. Finlay (pen.)
- 82'S. Mendoza ↑J. Hernández ↓
- 83'David VillaAssist: A. Pirlo
- 85'A. Jahn ↑Justin Meram ↓
- 90'Tony Tchani
- 90+2'David Villa (pen.)
- 90+5'E. Finlay
Expected Goals (ASA)
Score
Columbus Crew3
New York City FC3
xG
Columbus Crew2.10
New York City FC2.31
xPoints
Columbus Crew1.14
New York City FC1.59
New York City FC ←
→ Columbus Crew
0' – 94'25 of 25 shots
0'47'94'
Team
Body
Pattern
Columbus CrewNew York City FCFootHeaderGoalMarker size = xG
Period Breakdown
| Period | Columbus Crew | New York City FC | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G | xG | Sh | G | xG | Sh | |
| 1H | 0 | 0.16 | 6 | 1 | 1.16 | 6 |
| 2H | 3 | 2.10 | 10 | 2 | 1.24 | 3 |
| Total | 3 | 2.26 | 16 | 3 | 2.40 | 9 |
Match stats
Columbus CrewNew York City FC
- 54%Possession46%
- 16Shots9
- 6Shots on target6
- 6Shots off target2
- 4Blocked shots1
- 8Shots inside box7
- 8Shots outside box2
- 470Passes401
- 390Accurate passes327
- 83%Pass accuracy82%
- 8Corners2
- 4Offsides1
- 9Fouls15
- 1Yellow cards0
- 0Red cards0
- 3Saves2
Lineups
Columbus Crew
Formation: 4-2-3-1
Starting XI
Goalkeeper
- 1S. Clark
Defenders
- 4M. Parkhurst
- 25H. Afful
- 14W. Francis
- 24N. Næss
Midfielders
- 10F. Higuaín
- 6T. Tchani
- 9Justin Meram
- 13E. Finlay
- 20W. Trapp
Forwards
- 17O. Kamara
Substitutes
- 16H. Jiménez
- 11C. Mabwati
- 12A. Jahn
- 8M. Saeid
- 41B. Stuver
- 5D. Duka
- 2T. Wahl
Coach: G. Berhalter
New York City FC
Formation: 4-3-3
Starting XI
Goalkeeper
- 12J. Saunders
Defenders
- 51Andoni Iraola
- 2J. Hernández
- 13F. Brillant
- 4M. Chanot
- 27R. Allen
Midfielders
- 21A. Pirlo
- 8F. Lampard
- 15T. McNamara
Forwards
- 7David Villa
- 99T. Taylor
Substitutes
- 11J. Harrison
- 22R. Matarrita
- 9S. Mendoza
- 6F. Bravo
- 23Jefferson Mena
- 25E. Johansen
- 5M. Lopez
Coach: P. Vieira
Top performers
Columbus Crew- Ethan Finlay2G90'8.4
- Wil Trapp90'7.6
- Waylon Francis1A61'7.3
- Nicolai Naess90'6.9
- Justin Meram1G85'6.9
New York City FC- Andrea Pirlo1A90'8.3
- David Villa2G90'7.9
- Frank Lampard1G90'7.2
- Frederic Brillant90'7.0
- R.J. Allen69'6.9