Leagues CupQuarter-finalsFT (Pens 4-3)
Columbus Crew
1-1
HT (1-1)
New York City FCLower.com Field · Columbus, Ohio
Last 5 meetings
Full H2HL
Wed
Sep 17
2025
New York City FC
Columbus Crew3
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 26Yankee Stadium, BronxSergiy Boyko, Ukraine
D
Sat
Mar 22
2025
Columbus CrewNew York City FC0
0
HT 0-0Regular Season - 5Lower.com Field, ColumbusRubiel Vazquez, USA
W
Sat
Aug 31
2024
Columbus CrewNew York City FC4
2
HT 1-1Regular Season - 39Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioT. Unkel
W
Fri
Jun 14
2024
New York City FCColumbus Crew2
3
HT 1-0Regular Season - 25Yankee Stadium, New York CityA. Da Silva
D
Sat
Jul 8
2023
Columbus CrewNew York City FC1
1
HT 0-0Regular Season - 31Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioS. Boiko
Match events
- 1'A. Martínez
- 26'Christian McFarlaneFoul
- 41'C. HernándezAssist: M. Arfsten
- 65'K. O'Toole ↑C. McFarlane ↓
- 65'J. Haak ↑K. Parks ↓
- 69'M. Amundsen ↑Y. Cheberko ↓
- 75'B. Risa ↑S. Tanasijević ↓
- 76'M. Bakrar ↑A. Martínez ↓
- 84'J. Russell-Rowe ↑C. Ramirez ↓
- 84'D. Jones ↑M. Arfsten ↓
- 88'Santiago RodríguezFoul
- 90+2'M. Ilenič ↑T. Gray ↓
- 120+1'Thiago Martins (pen.)
- 120+2'R. Camacho (pen.)
- 120+3'M. Bakrar (pen.)
- 120+4'J. Russell-Rowe (pen.)
- 120+5'M. Moralez missed penalty
- 120+6'D. Rossi missed penalty
- 120+7'J. Sands (pen.)
- 120+8'C. Hernández (pen.)
- 120+9'S. Rodríguez missed penalty
- 120+10'D. Jones (pen.)
Match stats
Columbus CrewNew York City FC
- 53%Possession47%
- 18Shots5
- 6Shots on target3
- 8Shots off target1
- 4Blocked shots1
- 10Shots inside box4
- 8Shots outside box1
- 506Passes450
- 442Accurate passes364
- 87%Pass accuracy81%
- 7Corners5
- 3Offsides1
- 3Fouls16
- 0Yellow cards2
- 2Saves5
Lineups
Columbus Crew
Formation: 3-4-2-1
Starting XI
Goalkeeper
- 28P. Schulte
Defenders
- 31Steven Moreira
- 4R. Camacho
- 21Y. Cheberko
Midfielders
- 23M. Farsi
- 25S. Zawadzki
- 6D. Nagbe
- 27M. Arfsten
Forwards
- 17C. Ramirez
- 10D. Rossi
- 9C. Hernández
Substitutes
- 18M. Amundsen
- 19J. Russell-Rowe
- 12D. Jones
- 16T. Habroune
- 13A. Jackson
- 14Y. Yeboah
- 1N. Hagen
- 5D. Jones
- 20A. Mățan
- 7D. Chambost
- 2M. Herrera
Coach: W. Nancy
New York City FC
Formation: 4-2-3-1
Starting XI
Goalkeeper
- 49M. Freese
Defenders
- 24T. Gray
- 13Thiago Martins
- 12S. Tanasijević
- 18C. McFarlane
Midfielders
- 55K. Parks
- 6J. Sands
- 17H. Wolf
- 27M. Moralez
- 10S. Rodríguez
Forwards
- 16A. Martínez
Substitutes
- 22K. O'Toole
- 80J. Haak
- 5B. Risa
- 9M. Bakrar
- 35M. Ilenič
- 26A. Ojeda
- 7J. Mijatović
- 11J. Fernández
- 30T. Romero
- 1L. Barraza
- 2R. Hope-Gund
Coach: N. Cushing
Top performers
Columbus Crew- Cucho Hernández1G90'8.3
- Steven Moreira90'7.3
- Yevhen Cheberko69'7.3
- Mohamed Farsi90'7.3
- Sean Zawadzki90'7.3
New York City FC- Matthew Freese90'7.9
- Alonso Martínez1G76'7.5
- Thiago Martins90'7.2
- James Sands90'7.2
- Hannes Wolf90'6.9