Form Guide
Overview
DashboardForm GuideStandings
Analysis
SimulatedRolling FormStrength of Schedule
Stats
League StatsPlayer Stats
Fixtures
ScheduleHead to Head
News
News & Blogs
External
Old Form Guide
Sign in
Loading match…
Major League Soccer·MLS Cup - Conference Semi-finals·FT
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
4-1
HT (1-0)
New York City FCNew York City FC
Wed, Nov 1, 2017·12:00 AM UTC·MAPFRE Stadium (Columbus, Ohio)

Last 5 meetings

Full H2H
L
Wed
Sep 17
2025
New York City FCNew York City FC
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
3
2
Major League Soccer
HT 1-1Regular Season - 26Yankee Stadium, BronxSergiy Boyko, Ukraine
D
Sat
Mar 22
2025
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
New York City FCNew York City FC
0
0
Major League Soccer
HT 0-0Regular Season - 5Lower.com Field, ColumbusRubiel Vazquez, USA
W
Sat
Aug 31
2024
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
New York City FCNew York City FC
4
2
Major League Soccer
HT 1-1Regular Season - 39Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioT. Unkel
D
Sat
Aug 17
2024
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
New York City FCNew York City FC
1
1
Leagues Cup
HT 1-1PENQuarter-finalsLower.com Field, Columbus, OhioJ. Dickerson
W
Fri
Jun 14
2024
New York City FCNew York City FC
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
2
3
Major League Soccer
HT 1-0Regular Season - 25Yankee Stadium, New York CityA. Da Silva
Note: advanced (ASA) stats are processed on a delay and may lag basic stats by up to a day after match completion.

Match events

  1. 6'
    O. Kamara
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽
  2. 56'
    🔁
    New York City FC
    R. Matarrita ↑
    R. Wallace ↓
  3. 58'
    Artur
    Assist: F. Higuaín
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽
  4. 69'
    Justin Meram
    Assist: O. Kamara
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽
  5. 74'
    🔁
    New York City FC
    Andraž Struna ↑
    E. White ↓
  6. 75'
    K. Manneh ↑
    Pedro Santos ↓
    Columbus Crew
    🔁
  7. 78'
    ⚽
    New York City FC
    David Villa
  8. 79'
    🔁
    New York City FC
    S. Okoli ↑
    J. Harrison ↓
  9. 88'
    L. Abubakar ↑
    F. Higuaín ↓
    Columbus Crew
    🔁
  10. 90+1'
    M. Abu ↑
    Artur ↓
    Columbus Crew
    🔁
  11. 90+3'
    H. Afful
    Assist: Justin Meram
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽

Expected Goals (ASA)

Score
Columbus Crew4
New York City FC1
xG
Columbus Crew2.58
New York City FC1.78
xPoints
Columbus Crew0.00
New York City FC0.00
0.51.01.52.02.53.015'30'45'60'75'90'105'HTCumulative xGGoal · Columbus Crew · 5' · Ola KamaraHGoal · Columbus Crew · 57' · ArturHGoal · Columbus Crew · 68' · Justin MeramHGoal · New York City FC · 77' · David VillaAGoal · Columbus Crew · 92' · Harrison AffulHColumbus Crew (xG)New York City FC (xG)Score: 4 — 1Final xG: 2.72 — 1.81
New York City FC ←
→ Columbus Crew
0' – 94'33 of 33 shots
0'47'94'
Team
Body
Pattern
Columbus CrewNew York City FCFootHeaderGoalMarker size = xG

Period Breakdown

PeriodColumbus CrewNew York City FC
GxGShGxGSh
1H11.64800.888
2H31.08610.9311
Total42.721411.8119

Lineups

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew

Starting XI

Substitutes

  • 19K. Manneh
  • 17L. Abubakar
  • 8M. Abu
  • 12A. Jahn
  • 14W. Francis
  • 28N. Hansen
  • 41B. Stuver
Coach: G. Berhalter
New York City FC
New York City FC

Starting XI

Substitutes

  • 22R. Matarrita
  • 32Andraž Struna
  • 9S. Okoli
  • 5M. Lopez
  • 15T. McNamara
  • 17J. Lewis
  • 25E. Johansen
Coach: P. Vieira