Form Guide
Overview
DashboardForm GuideStandings
Analysis
SimulatedRolling FormStrength of Schedule
Stats
League StatsPlayer Stats
Fixtures
ScheduleHead to Head
News
News & Blogs
External
Old Form Guide
Sign in
Loading match…
Major League Soccer·Regular Season - 33·FT
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
3-2
HT (1-1)
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
Sat, Sep 23, 2017·11:30 PM UTC·MAPFRE Stadium · Columbus

Last 5 meetings

Full H2H
W
Sat
Oct 18
2025
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
3
1
Major League Soccer
HT 1-1Regular Season - 34Lower.com Field, ColumbusMarcos de Oliveira, USA
D
Sat
Aug 30
2025
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
0
0
Major League Soccer
HT 0-0Regular Season - 29Sports Illustrated Stadium, HarrisonRubiel Vazquez, USA
D
Sun
Nov 3
2024
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
2
2
Major League Soccer
HT 0-0PENMLS Cup - Round 1Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New JerseyF. Dujic
L
Tue
Oct 29
2024
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
0
1
Major League Soccer
HT 0-1MLS Cup - Round 1Lower.com Field, Columbus, OhioT. Ford
W
Sun
Oct 20
2024
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
2
3
Major League Soccer
HT 0-2Regular Season - 51Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New JerseyG. Gonzalez
Note: advanced (ASA) stats are processed on a delay and may lag basic stats by up to a day after match completion.

Match events

  1. 6'
    J. Mensah
    Assist: F. Higuaín
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽
  2. 14'
    ⚽
    New York Red Bulls
    B. Wright-Phillips
    Assist: S. Davis
  3. 40'
    🟨
    New York Red Bulls
    Kemar Lawrence
  4. 42'
    Héctor Jimenez
    Columbus Crew
    🟨
  5. 46'
    🔁
    New York Red Bulls
    C. Lade ↑
    M. Murillo ↓
  6. 54'
    Justin Meram
    Assist: F. Higuaín
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽
  7. 57'
    Artur ↑
    M. Abu ↓
    Columbus Crew
    🔁
  8. 59'
    🔁
    New York Red Bulls
    G. Verón ↑
    S. Klještan ↓
  9. 66'
    J. Williams
    Assist: F. Higuaín
    Columbus Crew
    ⚽
  10. 68'
    K. Manneh ↑
    Justin Meram ↓
    Columbus Crew
    🔁
  11. 68'
    🔁
    New York Red Bulls
    M. Keita ↑
    A. Long ↓
  12. 71'
    Federico Higuaín
    Columbus Crew
    🟨
  13. 72'
    ⚽
    New York Red Bulls
    G. Verón (pen.)
  14. 73'
    🟨
    New York Red Bulls
    Bradley Wright-Phillips
  15. 75'
    J. Raitala ↑
    H. Jiménez ↓
    Columbus Crew
    🔁
  16. 86'
    🟨
    New York Red Bulls
    Muhammed Keita
  17. 90'
    Pedro Santos
    Columbus Crew
    🟨
  18. 90'
    Jukka Raitala
    Columbus Crew
    🟨

Expected Goals (ASA)

Score
Columbus Crew3
New York Red Bulls2
xG
Columbus Crew1.38
New York Red Bulls1.21
xPoints
Columbus Crew1.48
New York Red Bulls1.21
0.51.01.52.015'30'45'60'75'90'HTCumulative xGGoal · Columbus Crew · 5' · Jonathan MensahHGoal · New York Red Bulls · 13' · Bradley Wright-PhillipsAGoal · Columbus Crew · 53' · Justin MeramHGoal · Columbus Crew · 65' · Josh WilliamsHGoal · New York Red Bulls · 71' · Gonzalo VerónAColumbus Crew (xG)New York Red Bulls (xG)Score: 3 — 2Final xG: 1.39 — 1.24
New York Red Bulls ←
→ Columbus Crew
0' – 90'23 of 23 shots
0'45'90'
Team
Body
Pattern
Columbus CrewNew York Red BullsFootHeaderGoalMarker size = xG

Period Breakdown

PeriodColumbus CrewNew York Red Bulls
GxGShGxGSh
1H10.88610.379
2H20.51510.873
Total31.391121.2412

Match stats

Columbus CrewNew York Red Bulls
  • 43%Possession57%
  • 11Shots12
  • 6Shots on target5
  • 3Shots off target4
  • 2Blocked shots3
  • 7Shots inside box7
  • 4Shots outside box5
  • 357Passes454
  • 261Accurate passes366
  • 73%Pass accuracy81%
  • 4Corners5
  • 7Offsides1
  • 14Fouls14
  • 4Yellow cards3
  • 0Red cards0
  • 3Saves3

Lineups

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
Formation: 4-2-3-1

Starting XI

Goalkeeper
  • 23Z. Steffen
Defenders
  • 25H. Afful
  • 4J. Mensah
  • 3J. Williams
  • 16H. Jiménez
Midfielders
  • 10F. Higuaín
  • 8M. Abu
  • 9Justin Meram
  • 20W. Trapp
  • 32Pedro Santos
Forwards
  • 11O. Kamara

Substitutes

  • 7Artur
  • 19K. Manneh
  • 2J. Raitala
  • 17L. Abubakar
  • 18C. Martinez
  • 28N. Hansen
  • 30L. Ketterer
Coach: G. Berhalter
New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
Formation: 5-4-1

Starting XI

Goalkeeper
  • 31L. Robles
Defenders
  • 55D. Perrinelle
  • 92K. Lawrence
  • 29F. Escobar
  • 33A. Long
  • 62M. Murillo
Midfielders
  • 16S. Klještan
  • 8Felipe Martins
  • 27S. Davis
  • 4T. Adams
Forwards
  • 99B. Wright-Phillips

Substitutes

  • 5C. Lade
  • 30G. Verón
  • 10M. Keita
  • 7D. Etienne
  • 15S. Zizzo
  • 18R. Meara
  • 19A. Muyl
Coach: J. Marsch

Top performers

Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
  • Federico Higuaín3A90'8.0
  • Pedro Santos90'7.6
  • Josh Williams1G90'7.4
  • Justin Meram1G68'7.2
  • Jonathan Mensah1G90'6.9
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
  • Bradley Wright-Phillips1G90'7.4
  • Sacha Kljestan59'7.2
  • Gonzalo Verón1G31'7.2
  • Damien Perrinelle90'7.1
  • Tyler Adams90'6.9